Vocal comping feature

2 replies [Last post]
Dan Weatherill
User offline. Last seen 8 years 19 weeks ago. Offline
Joined: 2007-05-21

I'm having to do a lot of vocal comping at the moment - i.e compiling a lead vocal track from about 6 or 7 full takes of a song. During the recording phase, ardour's playlist system is absolutely fantastic. Every take you just click new playlist and you're ready to go again. During the mix stage it's a bit more complicated. I currently have to make 6 or 7 new tracks, load the appropriate playlist into each track, then slowly go through auditioning each bit. Then I make yet a new blank track and chop up the others and compile my vocal track on the new blank track.

In cubase, there is a feature that lets you view all the "playlists" (though they're not quite the same as in ardour) on a single track and switch between them very easily. I think this system has advantages but also lacks some kind of flexibility.

I think it'd be great if there was a macro type feature which would make new blank tracks pre-loaded with the playlists from a current track. For example, right clicking on a track name and clicking something like "make new tracks from playlists". Ideally a "solo groups" feature would be great as well, so you could select this group of tracks and set the soloing up so that only one can ever be audible at a time. Maybe there's already a provision for this, I don't know?

Anyway, I think this feature might be quite easy to implement and would save at least 5 minutes of fiddling with tracks and playlists every time you need to comp a track.

thanks for listening

User offline. Last seen 9 years 15 weeks ago. Offline
Joined: 2007-09-17

Digging up an old post here...

It would be nice with a GREAT vocal comp feature. Pro Tools HD has one, Logic 8 has an AMAZING one. I would like to see Ardour steal that and perfect it ;)

User offline. Last seen 8 years 26 weeks ago. Offline
Joined: 2007-04-22

For the kind of stuff I'm doing, it's pretty much the only thing lacking right now, now that native OS X support has been done :-D